The offseason lack of interest in Pete Alonso was surprising, as projections estimated he would receive a lucrative multi-year deal, yet he ultimately re-signed with the Mets for just two years and $54 million. Despite concerns about age and the declining value of first basemen, Alonso has performed exceptionally well early in the season, leading the National League in several offensive categories and producing significant value. This raises questions about team valuation strategies and whether they undervalue the impact a power-hitting first baseman can have in critical game situations.